How do you answer the steel objection?
A friend says the Book of Mormon gets ancient steel wrong. They bring up Laban’s sword, Nephi’s bow, and Shule arming his followers.
Your question from the walkthrough
Return to the walkthroughYour walkthrough notes
Exchange 1 of 4
“Could Laban really have had a steel sword in Jerusalem?”
Exchange 2 of 4
“How could Nephi break a bow made of steel?”
Exchange 3 of 4
“Would carrying Laban’s sword across the ocean explain Ether?”
Exchange 4 of 4
“I found a paper showing pre-Columbian iron beads. Would that verify the steel swords?”
A response you could give
Which passage are we testing? Laban’s blade fits Iron Age technology near Jerusalem. Nephi’s bow may reflect older English usage. Ether and the early Nephite references make a different claim about working steel after arrival. I believe the Book of Mormon is scripture. To verify that particular claim archaeologically, I would want a securely dated American find and evidence of the right kind of metalworking.