Did the JST use Adam Clarke?
A friend points to two overlaps between Adam Clarke’s commentary and the Joseph Smith Translation. Read the sources and decide what each overlap can show.
Your question from the walkthrough
Return to the walkthroughYour walkthrough notes
Exchange 1 of 3
“They both use the word complaint in Romans 11. What does that show?”
Exchange 2 of 3
“What about the same clause moving to the same place in Colossians?”
Exchange 3 of 3
“If Joseph used a commentary, could the translation still be inspired?”
A response you could give
Clarke is a plausible source for some edits. Romans shares one natural word. Colossians shares a more specific structural move that Dickinson’s later version also makes. I would compare how distinctive each match is before calling it borrowing. I believe study and inspiration can work together, and I am open to evidence about how Joseph made a particular revision.